Sunday, April 13, 2014

The Hobbit

It’s a fantasy kind of day.  Just watched the second Hobbit film, and am stoked for Game of Thrones tonight.  My favorite genre has finally hit the mainstream in a way that I couldn’t have imagined as a kid.  Every big film it seems is either a big fantasy hit or a comic book adaptation.

I know this opinion is probably not shared by lovers of the book, but honestly, I think these Hobbit movies are better than the book.  I don’t say that to talk down about the book.  I love that book.  It is certainly more enjoyable than the trilogy that followed, but it isn’t as exciting, or, honestly, as deep, as the films are.

If Tolkien had written that book in the style the movies took, I think it would have been better.  There is an awful lot of plodding along in The Hobbit.  It has exciting moments, but the movie makes these moments connect better, and the changes to the storyline, such as giving the dwarves actual personality and showing Gandalf’s struggle against the Necromancer (as well as the interactions with Radagast the Brown), provide a lot more satisfaction to me.

So, instead of decrying the changes against a book that isn’t any more sacred than any other story adapted to the screen, I’m happy with them.  I like seeing Bard given more significance.  I enjoy the orc plotline.  Bolg is scary.  The Defiler is even more so.  It adds more tension.  Instead of random events that the company must endure, we have a common plotline that runs through the entire story.

That’s just better storytelling.

I know Tolkien is a titan in my genre, but he isn’t beyond reproach.  Some parts of his work are plain boring.  Some liberty is necessary, I think, or else the films would have just been a lot of walking and singing.

Now, the changes to Game of Thrones, I think, are more troubling.  That’s a whole other blog post waiting to be written.  That story is complex enough already without adding and subtracting characters, making up new things and deleting other things.  I fear if they aren’t careful they’ll have to deviate quite a bit before it’s over.

I expected things to be cut from Game of Thrones, not added.

But I’ll wax about that some other time.

Fantasy is in.  I’m so happy about that.  Comic books are in.  I’m ecstatic about that as well.

When I was a kid reading the Chronicles of Prydain and Thor and Spiderman and Superman, and to be honest, almost ALL of the comics that are being made into blockbusters now, I was on the outside of the mainstream.  Now I’m smack in the middle of it.

It’s kind of odd.

Hopefully my stories will capture someone’s imagination one day.  They’ve certainly captured mine.  I like telling them.

Now I’m off to go help shear some alpacas, because hobby farming is simultaneously fun and nerve wracking.

No comments:

Post a Comment