Tuesday, April 8, 2014

Blue Ink, Red Ink

I’ve always considered myself a discovery writer, or a gardener to use George R. R. Martin’s terminology.  This is probably because my first advice about writing came from Stephen King.

That advice came from the afterwords and arguments in his Dark Tower novels.  He spoke openly about the process he used to write them.  He didn’t know where they were going.  What’s up with the rose?  He didn’t know?  Will Roland get to the tower?  He didn’t know.

He was just along for the ride, so to speak.

I don’t have a Wayback Machine, or some way to see how the Present would have turned out differently if I’d also found a writer whose work I liked openly talk about outlining and the power of planning.  If, say, Brandon Sanderson had been publishing back when I was a kid, and instead of an amazing series of Youtube videos, he had put afterwords in his books about his process, then I might have taken a more balanced approach to learning how to write.

For a long time, a really long time, I tried to discovery write everything.  I started with a character, or perhaps a situation, and even if I had an ending or plot in mind, I just let it grow.

This works for a lot of writers.  George R. R. Martin is discovery writing A Song of Ice and Fire, which is as amazing as it is scary (as a fan).

It has made a career for Stephen King.  His son, Joe Hill, once said that, “Outlines are for dead things.”

Stephen King once said that “Outlines are the last resort of a bad fiction writer.”

Or something to that effect.

Here’s the rub though.  There is nothing wrong with outlining.  It’s wrong for them.  That much is obvious.  There are a lot of great books that were outlined.  There are a lot of great writers that are outliners.

Stephen King even admits that one of his favorite works, his own works, was tightly plotted.  He talks about how he liked the way The Dead Zone turned out.  He knew where that one was going.

Yet he still liked it.  And, from the way it sounded in On Writing, he liked it better than most.

All these years writing stories and getting stuck halfway through, or getting to the end and looking at it in disgust, could have probably been avoided if I’d known that I had only heard half the argument.  The other half is equally as important, and in some cases just as dogmatic, as the first.

So here is the method I’m using.  It’s kind of a hybrid, and most writers tend to fall somewhere in the middle, or so I’ve heard.

I outlined my book before I began.  I came up with some cool setting elements, did some follow through world building based on those elements, and then did a 1,000 outline of the plot and small snippets about the characters.

The entire document was under 3,000 words.  It took a few days, and I’m glad I did it.

But here’s the other rub.  Even though I had an outline, my finished product is WAY off track.  I had cool things come up, and I went with them.  Old habits die hard.  I didn’t stick strictly to my plan.  My end product is kind of a mess, but all rough drafts are a mess.  At one point I made myself a note using Track Changes in Word that I was going to fix a few things at the beginning to make the end match up.

So now that the rough draft is done, I’m going back and outlining again.  I’m making notes longhand, and it’s going well.  I figure that now that the rough draft is done, I need an even more detailed plan about what I like in the rough draft, and what I plan on changing.

I have a much longer outline that I began with, the parts written already in blue ink, and the parts I’m going to add in red.  I’m using Jim Butcher’s method of outlining, according to an old post I found in his Goodreads blog.  He does a page for each character, and draws a large arc from one end of the page to the other and puts all the scenes as dots along the arc, and then does explanations of the scenes.

I’ve broken my book down into scenes and settings, and I’m making notes on them.  I’m surprised at how few settings there are.  This is good, though.  I can spruce up a few places and they’ll really pop.

It’s time to go to work.  Day job.

Hopefully I’ll have a productive lunch break.

No comments:

Post a Comment