Tuesday, April 22, 2014

Escapism Versus Stories With Meaning

Whenever someone wants to put down the genres I love, they call it escapism, or escapist literature if they want to be really snarky.

I’ve heard it my whole life. Sometimes it came from teachers in school. Other times it came from reviews of books I love. I’ve heard it refer to comics, to epic fantasy, to science fiction, to pretty much everything except what people consider “mainstream” literature.

And I’ve got to be honest. At times, I find that philosophy creeping into my own mind. When I read something like All the Pretty Horses by Cormac McCarthy or Mildred Pierce by James M. Cain (which is considered “hard boiled”, a term that I find to be about the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard), it almost seems to me to be some higher form of storytelling, and I find myself being snobby about it. It’s something that has been drilled into our view of the world. I even hear it from my own mother.

But you know, it’s such bullshit. Mildred Pierce is a great book. James M. Cain is a great author. So is Cormac McCarthy.

And so is Stephen King. Some of the books I like most are by him.

And so is J. R. R. Tolkien, although sometimes I’ll admit the Lord of the Rings gets terribly boring.

But it’s taken half a century for the world to get around to recognizing how awesome some of these things are. (Not the whole world, mind you, just the part that has somehow took upon themselves to decide for the rest of us what “good” literature is.)

With graphic novels like Watchmen and Road to Perdition out there, and outstanding comics like Sandman, I don’t see how anyone could call comics some lower form of fiction.

With truly epic and awesome fantasies like The Name of the Wind and A Game of Thrones out there, how can anyone be snide towards fantasy?

And with science fiction, where do I even begin? Dune? Ender’s Game?

There is a list a mile long for every supposed escapist genre.

And that goes with horror as well. Joe Hill is writing some amazing books. I still look forward to Stephen King’s books.

And that’s kind of the whole point. Some of these stories don’t strive to have some kind of higher meaning, or some great big point, and that’s okay. Not every story has to, and to be honest, I think sometimes the stories suffer when the author decides he/she has something so damned amazing to say that they craft an entire story around their point. (Yes, I just blogged about writing satire, and that is kind of the definition of satire—having something to say and writing a story that says it—but I stand by splitting these hairs. Sometimes you’re writing satire, and sometimes you’re writing polemical fiction that doesn’t really stand on its own as fiction)

There is absolutely nothing wrong with escapism. If I want to read an amazing story that whisks me away from this world for a few hours, then that is my business. If a writer wants to write a story that accomplishes that, it is his/her business. And no one has any damned right to make them feel less accomplished or as if their taste isn’t as refined because of it.

The simple truth, so far as I can tell, is that a good story is a good story. Polemical fiction can be great, so long as the actual story within the message is good. I’m not saying that every story is great, no matter the genre, no matter the message or lack of one. Bad writing is out there. There is way more bad than good out there. Even those stories that are published. I’ve picked up some pretty awful books in my day. Books that just wrinkle your brow and make you wonder what kind of dirt they had on the publisher.

This is something I’ve thought about a lot, because it has influenced how I approach writing. I’ll catch myself thinking things like, “Well, I don’t want my first novel to be—insert genre here—because I won’t be taken as seriously.”

Or, “If I write something like—insert “higher” form of literature here—then I’ll be held in higher esteem.”

And I wonder why I even care. Honestly, those thoughts pass through my mind and after I’ve had a moment to process ‘em, I wonder why I am wasting precious time on this kind of BS.

Why does anyone?

There are people out there that we, as fans of science fiction, fantasy, horror, comics, graphic novels, tabletop gaming, and whatever else, will never convince. They’ll live their whole lives thinking that because the books they read don’t have dragons or spaceships that they’re somehow spending their time better than us.

And you know what? I kind of feel sorry for them. They’ll never enjoy Firefly or Serenity. They’ll never get the giddy feeling I do when I watch Game of Thrones and recognize characters from the book that I’ve been waiting to see on the screen for years. (Prince Oberyn, I’m looking at you.)

Sucks for them, because our passions are quickly becoming the mainstream. It’s awesome.

But the snobs are still out there. I’m not sure why I care, but it bothers me. It bothers me a lot. There isn’t enough time in all the days left in my life to go around trying to convince the people who look down on the kinds of literature I love to feel otherwise, but still, here I am spending time on a blog about it.

And the rub of it is, I want the things I write to do what a few others have done, which is to reach across those boundaries. You’ve got mainstream critics talking about George R. R. Martin in serious terms, as they damn well should. That dude’s awesome at what he does. I don’t think anyone tells a story better. And I mean anyone.

So, I’m at the end of this long and rambling blog post. I don’t think I quite got it to say all I wanted to, or with the elegance I had imagined.

That’s nothing new.

I also haven’t had a chance to read over it. I rarely proofread my blog posts. I know that’s lazy, but I spend a lot of time type editing my fiction, and the thought of doing the same with blog posts just makes me want to crawl under my desk and hibernate.

(Actually, I just did a bit of proofreading. I was worried I was doing the titles wrong. I looked it up, and the internet basically said it was all right, which is another way of saying that people have taken sides on a grammatical issue and half will think you’re wrong and the other half probably won’t give enough of a crap to pat you on the back for doing it right. Thanks grammar.)

Well, off to write what I hope will be a funny, witty, and memorable satirical short story about advertising.

To those who read this, please be kind about whatever errors have snuck past me.

No comments:

Post a Comment